Starter Motor Repair

Mod Description
If your engine won't even turn but you can bump start it and it runs fine, you may be looking at a duff starter motor.
Mod Details
PremiumNo Difficulty Mod ID739 Creditevilution For450 Fortwo452 Roadster Linkhttps://dev.evilution.co.uk/mod/starter-motor-repair.htm Copy to Clipboard

Checks Before Removal

You can do a few cursory checks with the starter motor in place if you have a Multimeter. Put the multimeter on the voltage setting and plug in both probes.Firstly it makes sense to check the battery because if that is flat, the starter won’t work. Place the black probe of the multimeter on the negative terminal of the battery and the red probe on the positive terminal of the battery. A healthy battery will be just over 12 volts, anything too much under that might not have enough power to start the car.

View the connections on the solenoid of the starter motor.

Connection A goes to the battery via the alternator. Place the black probe onto the casing of the starter motor. Put the red probe on to connection A. The multimeter should read just above 12 volts. If it doesn’t then the cabling to the starter could be damaged or burnt.

Leave the black probe on the casing and place the red probe on connection B. Get a friend/relative/prostitute to try and start the car. For a few seconds the multimeter should read just over 12 volts. If it doesn’t then then either the wire to the fuse box (SAM/ZEE) is faulty, the starter fuse has blown or the relay has failed.

When the friend/relative/hooker attempted to start the car, did you hear a click? If not then the solenoid is probably seized. If you did hear a click then the solenoid is working so you need to move to the next check.

Place the black probe on the casing of the starter motor and the red probe on connection C. Get the helper to try and start the car again. You should see just over 12 volts for a few seconds, if not then the connections at the back of the solenoid could be burnt or corroded.

If you did see 12+ volts and the car still isn’t starting then the actual starter motor is at fault. It could be seized through water ingress, jammed up with debris or the brushes could be faulty.

Time To Bust It Open

Remove the starter motor from the car

"

Checking, Disassembly, Cleaning and Maintenance

The cog you can see is called the Bendix, this moves forward and spins to start the engine. Check the bendix isn’t damaged and has no missing teeth.

OK, time to disassemble. Remove the 13mm nut and slide the jumper cable off the stud.

Remove the 3x 8mm nuts from the solenoid casing.

Pull the casing off to reveal the resting spring and the solenoid piston.

A solenoid is an electromagnet that, when energised, pulls or pushes a metal piston. Below you can see the piston in the resting position with the bendix hidden.

When the solenoid is activated, the piston pulls back and a lever moves the bendix forward.

Look into the solenoid, at the end is a button. When the piston is drawn back it presses this button which bridges the contacts between the battery cable and the starter motor. This passes power to the motor so it spins.

Over time, high amperage connections can suffer from spark erosion. This creates a build up of carbon on the contacts which means the power doesn’t make it to the motor as the switch can’t complete the circuit. A good spray of switch cleaner should work wonders.

Reassemble the solenoid and then remove both 4mm allen bolts holding the motor casing on.

Remove the 2x 7mm bolts from the end cover, remove the cover and slide the C clip out.

Push the spindle and pull the top off the motor housing then pull the central housing off too.

With it all apart, give it a good clean with brake/clutch cleaner spray.

Below are the 2 brushes (arrowed). Check to make sure they are OK and they spring forwards.

Have a good clean up, lightly lubricate moving parts and reassemble. Refit it to the car and hopefully it’ll work as it should.

Burning

Simon M thought he had a start motor issue but what he actually had was an alternator issue that then created a starter motor issue.

His alternator had started to seized which made the engine much harder to turn. This put too much power through the starter motor commutator which heated everything up. That caused the carbon brushes to burn and overheat the commutators which caused them to lift.

Lifted and damaged commutators then go on to damage the carbon brushes even more.

You’ll have to unseize the alternator and then fit a replacement starter motor.